Menus

Chopped

Hearts of romaine, seasoned chicken, gorgonzola, green onions, red onions, heirloom tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, ditalini pasta, homemade creamy Italian dressing.

$14.49

Burrata

Mixed greens, hand-ties burrata, fire-roasted heirloom tomatoes, homemade house dressing, balsamic glaze.

$14.89

Caesar

Hearts of romaine, pecorino romano, asiago, aged parmesan, garlic croutons, creamy Caesar dressing. Choose from single or entree.

$7.49

$9.49

Add Seasoned Chicken to single $2

Add Seasoned Chicken to entree $4

House

Mixed greens, fior di latte, heirloom tomatoes, red onions, garlic croutons. Choose from homemade house, bleu cheese or ranch. Comes in single or entree.

$7.49

$9.49

Add Seasoned Chicken to single $2

Add Seasoned Chicken to entree $4

Meatball

Bucatini pasta, Big Pauly's marinara, two hand-rolled, fire-roasted meatballs, pecorino romano, fresh basil.

$14.89

Add Extra Meatball $3.49

Alfredo

Penne pasta, homemade alfredo cream sauce, fresh garlic, aged parmesan.

$14.89

Add Seasoned Chicken $4

Baked Lasagna

Rigatoni pasta, Big Pauly's marinara, sauteed spinach, seasoned ricotta, whole milk mozzarella, pecorino romano, fresh basil.

$14.89

Add Fennel Sausage $4

Add Seasoned Chicken $4

Vodka

Penne pasta, homemade creamy vodka sauce, cremini mushrooms, peas, prosciutto di parma, grana padano, fresh basil.

$14.89

Old World Margherita

Extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, whole milk mozzarella, hand-crushed plum tomatoes, aged parmesan, fresh basil.

FAN FAVORITE - 16/18/25

St. Rocco

Big Pauly’s signature red sauce, whole milk mozzarella, fennel sausage, roasted peppers, red onions, cremini mushrooms, fresh basil.

The Butcher

Big Pauly's signature red sauce, whole milk mozzarella, hand-rolled, fire-roasted meatballs, pepperoni, fennel sausage, applewood smoked bacon, fresh basil.

Veggie Simbario

Big Pauly's signature red sauce, whole milk mozzarella, fresh garlic, red onions, heirloom tomatoes, cremini mushrooms, Mediterranean olives, green onions, fresh basil.

Wise Gals

Spinach and artichoke cream sauce, whole milk mozzarella, aged provolone and parmesan, seasoned chicken, sauteed spinach, artichoke hearts.

Cinque Formaggi (5 Cheese)

Big Pauly’s signature red sauce, aged pecorino romano, asiago, parmesan, provolone, whole milk mozzarella, sauteed spinach.

Smokin' Pauly

Fire-roasted red pepper coulis, smoked mozzarella, fennel sausage, roasted red peppers, red onions, fresh basil.

The Great White

Extra virgin olive oil, whole milk mozzarella, seasoned ricotta, fresh garlic, prosciutto di parma.

Buffalo Chicken

Cayenne pepper sauce, aged provolone, whole milk mozzarella, gorgonzola, buffalo seasoned breaded chicken, red onion.

Smokin' BBQ Chicken

Honey BBQ chicken, smoked mozzarella, whole milk mozzarella, applewood smoked bacon, red and green onions.

Pizza Alla Vodka

Vodka cream sauce, whole milk mozzarella, cremini mushrooms, peas, prosciutto di parma.

Disclaimer

Although we offer a gluten free pizza crust, we are not a gluten-free kitchen. Cross contamination could occur and our restaurant is unable to guarantee that this menu item can be completely free of allergens.

Big Pauly’s Signature Red Sauce and Whole Milk Mozzarella Included

10" Gluten Free

Add $2.00 Per Topping

$11.89

12" Original

Add $2.25 Per Topping

$14.49

16" Big Pauly

Add $3.00 Per Topping

$20.49

Disclaimer

Although we offer a gluten free pizza crust, we are not a gluten-free kitchen. Cross contamination could occur and our restaurant is unable to guarantee that this menu item can be completely free of allergens.

MEATS & CHEESES

Applewood Smoked Bacon, Buffalo Chicken, Capicola, Fennel Sausage, Fior Di Latte, Gorgonzola, Hand-Rolled Meatballs, Italian Beef, Pepperoni, Prosciutto Di Parma, Provolone, Seasoned Chicken, Seasoned Ricotta, Smoked Mozzarella, Soppressata, Whole Milk Mozzarella

VEGETABLES

Artichoke Hearts, Banana Peppers, Fresh Basil, Black Olives, Cremini Mushrooms, Fresh Garlic, Heirloom Tomatoes, Hot Giardiniera, Jalapenos, Mediterranean Olives, Red Onions, Roasted Peppers, Sauteed Spinach

Little Pauly Pizza

Choose from cheese, sausage or pepperoni.

$8.49

Baked Mac & Cheese

Cavatappi pasta, homemade five-cheese cream sauce.

$8.49

Add Seasoned Chicken $2

Little Pauly Pasta & Meatball

Bucatini pasta, Big Pauly's marinara, one hand-rolled, fire-roasted meatball, pecorino romano, fresh basil.

$8.49

Add Extra Meatball $3.49

Pasta with Butter

Cavatappi pasta tossed in butter and topped with fresh Italian parsley.

$8.49

Affogato Espresso

Hot Espresso poured over vanilla bean gelato. DINE-IN ONLY!

$6

Featured Gelato

Two scoops of premium hand-crafted gelato. Seasonal and for a limited time.

$5

Chocolate Chip Cannoli

Crispy pastry shell stuffed with ricotta cheese and chocolate chips.

$3.50

Death By Chocolate Cake

Triple chocolate cake with creamy chocolate mousse and dark chocolate ganache.

$6.50

Vanilla Bean Gelato

Two scoops of premium, hand-crafted gelato drizzled with chocolate.

$3

Tiramisu

Espresso soaked lady fingers topped with mascarpone cream.

$7

Marlowe's Milk Shakes

Turn any of our desserts into a delicious, hand-crafted milk shake. Choose from Chocolate Chip Cannoli, Death By Chocolate Cake, Gelato, or Tiramisu.

$8

Fountain Drinks

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Wild Cherry Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer, Sierra Mist, Lemonade, Unsweetened Iced Tea

$2.95

Free refills

Milk & Apple Juice

Kid's Color Changing Collector's Cup Included

$2.95

Refills $0.95

Sprecher Craft Soda

Choose from Cream Soda or Root Beer

$3.25

Coca-Cola

12oz. Bottle

$2.95

San Benedetto Sparkling Water

Product of Italy (1 pint)

$2.95

Bottled Water

$1.25

Regular & Decaf Coffee, Hot Tea

DINE-IN ONLY!

$2.25

Espresso

DINE-IN ONLY!

$3.95