Menus

Bruschetta

Garlic toast, vine ripe plum tomatoes, fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh basil, pecorino romano, homemade basil vinaigrette.

$8
Garlic Knots

Baked dough, fresh garlic butter, aged parmesan, fresh Italian parsley. Served with Big Pauly's marinara.

$6
Antipasti Platter

Chef's selection of imported Italian meats and cheeses, fire-roasted cherry tomatoes, Mediterranean olives, garlic toast.

$18
Homemade Meatballs

Wood-roasted, Big Pauly's marinara, pecorino romano, fresh basil.

$9
Jumbo Roasted Wings

Marinated, wood-roasted chicken wings in your choice of Spicy Buffalo, Bourbon BBQ or Mango Habanero. Served with ranch or bleu cheese.

$9

Chopped

Hearts of romaine, seasoned chicken breast, gorgonzola, green onions, red onions, heirloom cherry tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, ditalini pasta, homemade creamy Italian dressing.

$12
Caesar

Hearts of romaine, pecorino romano, asiago, aged parmesan, garlic croutons, creamy Caesar dressing.

Single $6

Entrée $9

Seasoned chicken breast (Single) $2

Seasoned chicken breast (Entrée) $4
House

Mixed greens, fior di latte, heirloom grape tomatoes, red onions, garlic croutons. Choose from homemade house, bleu cheese or ranch.

Single $6

Entrée $9

Seasoned chicken breast (Single) $2

Seasoned chicken breast (Entrée) $4
Caprese

Fior di latte, vine ripe plum tomatoes, fresh basil, roasted peppers, homemade basil vinaigrette.

$10

Pasta & Meatballs

Bucatini pasta, Big Pauly's marinara, homemade meatballs, pecorino romano, fresh basil.

$13

Extra Meatball $1.95
Penne Alla Vodka

Penne pasta, homemade creamy vodka sauce, cremini mushrooms, peas, prosciutto di parma, grana padano, fresh basil.

$14
Build Your Own Baked Mac & Cheese

Mixed pasta, homemade five-cheese cream sauce, applewood smoked bacon.

$12

To add each additional ingredient. $1.45

Homemade Meatball Sub

Wood-roasted, Big Pauly's marinara, fresh basil.

$10
Italian Beef Sandwich

Slow-roasted prime-cut beef, Italian seasonings, 4" bambino roll.
Sausage w/ Peppers & Onions

Wood-roasted sausage, roasted peppers and onions, 4" bambino roll.
Chicken Parmesan

Fresh Italian breaded chicken, Big Pauly's marinara, whole milk mozzarella, aged parmesan.

$9
To Add Regular or Smoked Mozzarella, Provolone, Roasted Peppers, Big Pauly's Marinara, or Hot Giardiniera to Any 4" Sandwich.

Only $0.49

Choose Your Size , Add Premium Toppings, and Watch as Your Pizza Bakes in Our Wood-Fired Brick Oven

Big Pauly’s signature red sauce and whole milk mozzarella included.
8" Single Serve

Choose from cheese, sausage or pepperoni. (Available daily from 11-2)

$7

Add for each additional topping $0.95
12" Original

$13

Add per topping $1.95
16" Big Pauly

$19

Add per topping $2.75
10" Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust

Disclaimer: Although we offer a gluten free pizza crust, we are not a gluten-free kitchen. Cross contamination could occur and our restaurant is unable to guarantee that this menu item can be completely free of allergens.

$11

Add per topping $1.45

Little Pauly Pizza

Choose from cheese, sausage or pepperoni.

Add for each additional topping $0.95
4" Bambino Sandwich

Choose from Italian beef or sausage, chicken parmesan or homemade meatball.
Build Your Own Baked Mac & Cheese

Mixed pasta, homemade five-cheese cream sauce, applewood smoked bacon.

Add for each additional ingredient $0.95
Little Pauly Meatball

Bucatini pasta, Big Pauly's marinara, homemade meatball, pecorino romano, fresh basil.
Pasta with Butter

Mixed pasta tossed in butter and topped with fresh Italian parsley.
All Kids Meals Come with Fresh Fruit and A 16 Oz. Fountain Drink in A Collector's Cup

(12 and under)

$8

Chocolate Chip Cannoli

Crispy pastry shell stuffed with ricotta cheese and chocolate chips

$3.50
Oreo Avalanche Cheesecake

Chocolate cheesecake, cookie crust, marshmallow, drizzle of dark chocolate, chunks of oreos

$6.50
Tiramisu

Espresso soaked lady fingers topped with mascarpone cream

$7
Marlowe's Milk Shakes

Turn any of our desserts into a delicious, hand-crafted milk shake

$8
Vanilla Bean Gelato

Two scoops drizzled with chocolate

$3
Add a Cup of Coffee or Tea to Any Dessert For $1.90

Sprecher Craft Soda

Choose from Cream Soda, Orange Dream or Root Beer

$3.25
Fountain Drinks

Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer, Sierra Mist, Lemonade, Raspberry Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea

$2.95

Free refills
Mexican Coke

$2.95
San Benedetto Artesian Water

Premium sparkling water imported from Italy (1 pint)

$2.95
Regular & Decaf Coffee, Hot Tea

$2.25
Bottled Water

$1.25

Starters